Friday, September 24, 2004

Flag Burning Amendment

I commented on this at Kerry Haters.

I believe the argument that this involves freedom of speech is ridiculous. The flag is property of our government, and thus belongs to everyone. This is true with our money and our monuments. So I ask, should the person who wants to burn the flag be able to deface the White House? Should they be able to destroy monuments? Wouldn't that, under the assumption of burning the flag, be the same thing?

I believe the most relevant comparison is with US currency and the flag. It is a federal offense to destroy MONEY. And I have yet seen any attorney successfully argue that a person has a right to destroy money as a basis for freedom of speech. Sure, if I burn a twenty, I probably won't go to jail. But it's still illegal. And if there were rampant money burning in a time of economic crisis--then the law would be enforced.

This would be true with the flag burning amendment. If we are all at piece and some hippie at a college wants to desecrate the flag for an art project--so be it. But if a person in a time of war wants to incite riots and blowback by burning the flag to demoralize our troops and to balk at our nation, then that law should be enforced.

What do you think of that comparison? Let me know in the comments.


KipEsquire said...

I'm not sure the money and White House analogies are appropriate, and I think the statement "the flag is government property" in the same sense that currency and the WHite House are "government property" is not sustainable.

By that analogy, it would be okay to ban burning a printout (done in Word by Little Green Footballs, of course!) of the Constitution -- after all, the Constitution is, by this line of reasoning, "government property" too, no?

STCA said...

What if we beat liberals at their own game and call flag buring "hate speech?"

Anonymous said...


buisness credit card
morgage loans bad credit

Anonymous said...

Hello all

Wow! This site is very good!

[url=]adult breastfeeding orgasm stories[/url]

[url=]almost legal teen sex[/url]

[url=]ameture black porno vids[/url]

[url=]anime cat girl xxx[/url]

[url=]artistic nude male galleries[/url]
best admin
Bjorn Steinhauer

Anonymous said...

Many thanks, yes I have received my full order with [url=]cheap accutane[/url] cheap accutane and [url=]hoodia[/url] hoodia. I have used other internet suppliers but you are the best of the best ! Thank you again for a brilliant product & service, [url=]buy hoodia[/url] buy hoodia and [url=]buy accutane[/url] buy accutane
- Kindest regards, Rod

Anonymous said...

Hi all!
[URL=]livesex cams[/URL]
[URL=]free livecams[/URL]
[URL=]airport live webcams[/URL]
[URL=]adult cam cam live[/URL]

Bookmark Widget